• picture
  • picture
  • picture
  • picture
Public Radio's Environmental News Magazine (follow us on Google News)

Seasonal Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese

Air Date: Week of

Living on Earth producers Jenni Doering and Aynsley O’Neill (above) joined Assistant Producer Bella Smith to make butternut squash macaroni and cheese for a special Thanksgiving-themed segment. (Photo: Bella Smith)

Mac and cheese, one of the most beloved comfort foods there is, can highlight a seasonal autumn vegetable – butternut squash. And the dish might just be the star of your Thanksgiving feast. Living on Earth’s Bella Smith joins Hosts Aynsley O’Neill and Jenni Doering for a cooking adventure with some sustainable tips to boot.



Transcript

DOERING: All right, Aynsley and I are here in my kitchen for some holiday cooking.

O'NEILL: And we're joined today by Living on Earth's Bella Smith. Hi, Bella.

SMITH: Hey, how's it going?

O'NEILL: Oh, it's going well, and we're all here to make a recipe together.

DOERING: Yes, Bella, you told us about your friend's butternut squash mac and cheese that is absolutely delicious, and because Thanksgiving is here, we thought we would make it with you.

SMITH: Yeah, my friend made this butternut squash mac and cheese for our Friendsgiving this year, and it was definitely a labor of love, but so so worth it. So I'm excited to share.

O'NEILL: Well, luckily there are three of us, and I think between us we will be able to actually make this happen, and hopefully in time for lunch.

DOERING: That's right. So yeah, just to make it easy, I already roasted the butternut squash in the oven. Pretty straightforward. There's shallots as well that are roasted, and now we have what, a whole bunch of cheese and some shells and other ingredients to throw together.

O'NEILL: I think we just need to get started.

DOERING: All right. So after the roasting happens, we're gonna make the topping. So we need a small bowl, and we're gonna get the panko and olive oil.

O'NEILL: I love topping mac and cheese with panko. You could do other breadcrumbs too. I sometimes will season this, but we're actually gonna do a lot of seasoning of the sauce itself. So if you want to put some in here, if you want to put some in the pasta, whatever you want to do, we're doing lots of herbs and aromatics and all of that. That'll be nice.

DOERING: That's right. Okay, so now we just need to get our pasta water going.

SMITH: This is so much less chaotic than when it was all six of my roommates cooking a Friendsgiving meal for 30 people at once.

O'NEILL: 30 people is really, I'm gonna say brave. I'm gonna say brave is what that is.

SMITH: Brave or foolish?

DOERING: That's a lot of people in your apartment.

SMITH: Yeah.

O'NEILL: Okay, so we're gonna scoop out what, two cups of butternut squash?

DOERING: Correct. Two cups of butternut squash in the blender. It's so orange.


A bright orange butternut squash is the perfect fall addition to creamy mac n’ cheese. (Photo: Jenni Doering)

O'NEILL: Yeah, this is beautiful. This is a beautiful butternut squash. Now I wish at a time like this that I'd have a good suggestion for what you could do with your squash peel, but I'm afraid I don't, so.

DOERING: Actually, I have an idea. So I looked this up when I was making acorn squash soup recently, and you can save the peels. You can put them in stock, vegetable stock. And what I do is I just take those scraps and I stick them in the freezer, instead of you know having to make all of the stock at once. But then if they're in the freezer, they just live in there until I'm ready to make my stock.

O'NEILL: That's perfect.

DOERING: I also think, I think butternut squash is kind of a sustainable vegetable in a way because they don't go bad very easily at all. You can have them sitting around for weeks on your counter and then get around to using them, and you can use pretty much the whole thing. I mean, the seeds you could roast.

O'NEILL: I, so I've actually never had roasted butternut squash seeds, but I always remember growing up. My family would do a jack-o'-lantern for Halloween, and we would always roast those pumpkin seeds. And then afterwards, my mom would take apart the pumpkin and turn it into a pumpkin soup. Now I've never suggested pumpkin mac and cheese to her, but I'm sure that would work as well too.

DOERING: And I think this is the pumpkin soup you've talked about on the broadcast before. Oh yeah, yeah, it sounded really good.

O'NEILL: It's very much a family tradition, and it's one of the things I look forward to every fall, basically.

DOERING: Okay, so we got the olive oil. We need the balsamic vinegar, two teaspoons, onion powder, garlic powder, and we'll get the sage out of the fridge.

O'NEILL: Yeah, and we're, we're following the recipe by rote, but you can definitely be seasoning to your heart's content. I feel like you could add, I don't know, some paprika, some smoked paprika, chipotle, probably cayenne if you want a little kick. All sorts of stuff you could do to dress this up.

DOERING: Okay, so sage is in, and I think nutmeg that's next on this list is going in there too. Yes, it is, and several grains of pepper. We're gonna use fresh nutmeg.

SMITH: We're really pulling out all the stops here.


Blending the sauce ingredients ensures the mixture is creamy and smooth before adding the cheese and pasta. (Photo: Bella Smith)

DOERING: Blend until creamy. So this is where, if stuff is hot and you're gonna be blending it like, for soup, you have to be careful about the expansion, and you, you don't want to put the lid on tight. You want to use like a cloth.

DOERING: It does look pretty blended.

O'NEILL: I think so.

DOERING: Okay, great.

SMITH: Yeah, nice.

DOERING: It looks so pretty. So the next step is return our pasta pot to the stove, which we have done, and we're gonna heat the almond milk. And you know, this is of course not a dairy-free recipe. But at least there's almond milk in it.

O'NEILL: There are cheese substitutes, and some which would be better for melting than others. But yeah, this is this is I feel like a recipe that you could really switch a lot of things out without it taking too much of a toll on consistency or flavor or all sorts of things like that. So yeah, for for folks with a nut allergy, I'm sure you could swap this out for cow's milk or any unsweetened, unflavored milk alternatives.

DOERING: Oat milk.

O'NEILL: Oat milk, I'm sure would work out great in this.

DOERING: Yeah. All right. So I guess that's cooking, and we can grate the cheese.

O'NEILL: Yes, we've got some Gruyere here.

DOERING: And this is a good sharp cheddar. It's extra sharp.

O'NEILL: And then it's what one and a half ounces?

DOERING: Only one and a half of the pecorino. I feel like to have something like this on the table, whether or not you have meat on the table. You know, this could be the star of the show for a vegetarian Thanksgiving. Maybe, maybe vegan too if you use vegan cheese. Somebody, somebody should try that out there and tell us.


Living on Earth's Assistant Producer Bella Smith brought us this autumnal recipe, which she first had at her Friendsgiving dinner. (Photo: Courtesy of Bella Smith)

SMITH: Yeah, we'd love to know how it how it tastes with vegan cheese.

DOERING: I would love to know.

SMITH: It's definitely the star of the show.

O'NEILL: Oh, what else did you have at your Friendsgiving?

SMITH: We had all the classics. I made mashed potatoes. One of my friends made stuffing. We did have roasted chicken and a really good like brussels, roasted walnut, pomegranate salad was also delicious. And then tons of desserts, lemon bars. It was, it was a feast.

DOERING: Pumpkin pie?

SMITH: No pumpkin pie actually. We were missing that.

O'NEILL: Pumpkin pie the day after for breakfast. That's a classic in my family.

DOERING: All right. So I guess we're just stirring this. This is going to end up looking a bit like, like a Kraft mac and cheese because this this orange butternut squash, except it's so much more real.

SMITH: Very, very different.

DOERING: It looks silky.

O'NEILL: Yeah, yeah, yeah. The cheese really did melt pretty well.

DOERING: Okay.

SMITH: Nice.

DOERING: So now we're just gonna put it in our other pan so we can broil it. So this says three to ten minutes. We just want it to be crisp and brown.


The mac and cheese broiled for a few minutes, just long enough to toast the Panko breadcrumbs. (Photo: Bella Smith)

O'NEILL: You know, baking is definitely going to add the, the extra caramelization and everything on top of that. But I'm sure this would also work out just fine if you just wanted to stir –

DOERING: Oh yeah.

O'NEILL: the pasta in a la your boxed mac and cheeses.

DOERING: Yeah.
O'NEILL: When I make a pumpkin mac and cheese, similar to this. I'll also often add pepitas or pumpkin seeds on top.

DOERING: Ooh, some crunch. Yum! The moment of truth.

O'NEILL: I know, we've now let it rest for say 15 minutes, and it's definitely looking and smelling delicious.

DOERING: I think we definitely worked up an appetite too.

O'NEILL: Yeah, yeah.

DOERING: Wow.

O'NEILL: Yeah.

DOERING: Yes.

O'NEILL: I'm taking a second. It looks a little warm to me still.

DOERING: It's, well.

O'NEILL: It's steaming.

DOERING: I know it was steaming, but I went for it.

SMITH: Yeah. Oh yeah. That's the stuff.


The finished product was nutty, cheesy, and delicious! (Photo: Bella Smith)

DOERING: We did a perfect job on this, actually. I think like, I taste the shallots. I taste the butternut squash, the cheese shells are perfectly cooked.

SMITH: And it's not like too cheesy. Not that a mac and cheese could really be, but the butternut squash makes it like, like nice and nutty.

O'NEILL: Mmm. That is really good. I know I was saying that I make a pumpkin mac and cheese. I may have a new favorite.

DOERING: Well, your roommate had a genius idea in making this.

SMITH: Thank you, Morgan, and also thank you, Love and Lemons.

DOERING: Yes, thank you, Love and Lemons. We'll post the recipe link on our website, loe.org. Well, this was a success. I think we should say from all of us here at Living on Earth, happy Thanksgiving.

O'NEILL: Yeah, happy Thanksgiving, everyone. Enjoy your food. Enjoy good times with good company and have a good time giving thanks.

SMITH: Happy Thanksgiving.

 

Links

Love & Lemons | “Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese”

Check out our previous coverage of Living on Earth Thanksgiving feast favorites

 

Living on Earth wants to hear from you!

Living on Earth
62 Calef Highway, Suite 212
Lee, NH 03861
Telephone: 617-287-4121
E-mail: comments@loe.org

Newsletter [Click here]

Donate to Living on Earth!
Living on Earth is an independent media program and relies entirely on contributions from listeners and institutions supporting public service. Please donate now to preserve an independent environmental voice.

Newsletter
Living on Earth offers a weekly delivery of the show's rundown to your mailbox. Sign up for our newsletter today!

Sailors For The Sea: Be the change you want to sea.

The Grantham Foundation for the Protection of the Environment: Committed to protecting and improving the health of the global environment.

Contribute to Living on Earth and receive, as our gift to you, an archival print of one of Mark Seth Lender's extraordinary wildlife photographs. Follow the link to see Mark's current collection of photographs.

Buy a signed copy of Mark Seth Lender's book Smeagull the Seagull & support Living on Earth